What it Means to Understand Numbers
byNovember 11th, 2016 All Blog Posts
I received my first diary when I was six or seven years old and recently rediscovered it in a box of childhood memories. Imagine my surprise when I opened the decades-old journal to find that my first, and most frequent, entry was arithmetic.
I had created a series of two and three-digit numbers that I then added or subtracted following a traditional column algorithm of carrying or borrowing.
“What little understanding this demonstrates,” I thought as I reflected on what it means to be able to reason with those two and three-digit numbers. It was not until much later in my own education that I recall wrapping my head around numbers, how they are composed and decomposed, and how the procedures I had followed by rote connected to any sense-making of my own.
Fast forward to my time with students in the classroom
I had the unique opportunity to teach Math Intervention at the middle school level, in classes of mixed 6th, 7th, and 8th graders, each of whom were two or more grade levels behind in math. My first thought when I was assigned this structure of class was, “How can I help an 8th grader with 8th grade mathematics while also helping a 6th grader with 6th grade mathematics?” Well, as I soon learned, the vast majority of struggles my students encountered with their grade-level mathematics were rooted in misunderstandings about numbers, our number system, how operations work, and many other foundational concepts. When I targeted instruction and crafted learning opportunities intended to fill in those conceptual holes, I found that the struggles with grade-level math practically addressed themselves.
The challenges were rooted in not understanding numbers
Taking a holistic approach to analyzing student misconceptions proved invaluable. Students needed me to structure their learning so that they developed their problem solving skills, reasoning abilities, and computational prowess. It was not through re-learning algorithms that students began to turn the tide of their previous failures in math, rather through:
- guided re-introduction of concepts around place value and the base ten number system,
- practice thinking flexibly about numbers,
- inviting students to re-invest in their own reasoning
My goal in facilitating high levels of math learning for students continues to be one that balances computation, problem solving, and number sense. With that focus, student commentary shifted from, “I forgot the next step” to “I know I can break down these numbers and work with them.” That’s when I knew we were making progress with understanding math, not just doing math.
Identifying and Targeting the Source of the Confusion
The most effective instruction is designed to identify and target the source of confusion, not to simply treat the symptoms
During my time with these struggling middle school students I did not know about Do The Math. As I’ve learned more about it I realize that it is designed to focus instruction on the core concepts at the heart of students’ struggles in mathematics. It builds students’ numerical fluency while still supporting problem solving and number sense. Think of this analogy:
When our hearts or any internal system isn’t functioning properly we often see symptoms in our health. Doctors treating symptoms only find themselves repeatedly addressing the same issues and never helping patients achieve true wellness. However, when doctors or specialists understand the connection between those internal systems and symptoms we often see patients return to wellness, indeed they begin to thrive.
So too is it the case with struggling learners. The most effective instruction, or path to “wellness,” is instruction designed to identify and target the source of the confusion (e.g., teaching number concepts), not to simply treat the symptoms (e.g., more practice with an algorithm).
Directly from the Source
Hear Marilyn Burns, creator of Do The Math, talk about lessons she’s learned from her classroom teaching experiences. During this EdWeek webinar (registration link below) Marilyn will address building a teaching bridge between math and reading, learning from one-on-one math interviews, and implementing effective instructional strategies.
Marilyn Burns, founder of Math Solutions, is a nationally recognized author and thought leader on teaching mathematics. Don’t miss this opportunity to hear directly from the source!
Developing Students’ Numerical Understanding and Skills With Marilyn Burns
Date: November 15, 2016
Time: 2:00 pm Eastern Standard Time.
UPDATE: You can now view Marilyn’s webinar here.
Jennifer Lenhardt designs and provides 6-12 professional development for teachers nationwide. She is passionate about supporting students who struggle in math by creating and facilitating instruction that targets the source of student confusion.